• 3 Posts
  • 85 Comments
Joined 4 years ago
cake
Cake day: May 8th, 2023

help-circle
  • It doesn’t sound particularly novel or non-obvious (especially if you substitute the last craze, like crypto) - just updating a single obvious detail like substituting crypto network operation for AI training.

    Of course, the bigger problem here is that unlike crypto applications, adversarial participants could influence the weights with the aim of producing Microsoft Tay v2, or could work together with a network of adversarial participants to get the weights and training data (now perhaps this essentially makes them public weights, given they probably can’t be copyrighted and at most Microsoft could try to crack down on adversarial participants through contract or maybe trade secret law - but once they are out, nothing would stop uninvolved others sharing them, and a mass protest act to release the weights with anonymous organisers would be hard to crack down on).


  • Good on the military police officer who actually held a soldier accountable for their crimes.

    But there are so many credible reports of widespread lack of accountability for things like killing civilians. I wonder what’s different here:

    • Is there an ick factor here that there isn’t when soldiers just shoot civilians or commit other war crimes, and this proves there is a war crime that crosses a line?
    • Or is this a principled MP who is risking harassment for doing the right thing when the unofficial standard is to turn a blind eye?
    • Or is this a performative sacrifice of one soldier so the powers that be have some examples to point to when people accuse them of war crimes, even if they are a tiny minority of actual war crimes, and most are ignored?
    • Or as a variant of the above, are MPs so rare and under-resourced that occasionally they do legit work, but they don’t have resources to push back the tide of war crimes meaningfully?
    • Or has the power of the biggest war criminals like Netanyahu, Smotrich, and so on waned after the election and we are finally seeing the tide turning?

  • Dodgy app developers make dodgy apps, and convince naive users to install them.

    The dodgy apps make the naive user’s Internet connection available to some partner the dodgy app developer has done a deal with - and since the naive user is typically using a residential network, and it lets their connection be used by someone else, it’s called a residential proxy.

    The partner sells access to a huge network of residential proxies to scrapers, often those wanting to do AI scraping against the wishes of the owners of the site being scraped. This is valuable to the scrapers because they appear to be coming from large numbers of different residential addresses. Cloud / hosting provider addresses are usually the first thing people block if they don’t want scrapers, and they also block how much each address can access. So the scrapers scrape a little bit per address, making it hard for the victim sites to detect what is scraping and what is legitimate traffic.

    This creates a security risk for the naive users, because as well as connecting out to the Internet, usually the proxy customer can connect to and maybe exploit things on their home network. The naive users usually don’t know their connection is being used this way.

    So the headline here is that one of the affected naive users is someone in the White House, and one of the ‘residential’ networks being sold is in fact the White House’s Internet connection.


  • You can do this cryptographically as an interactive zero-knowledge protocol without a third-party.

    This is easiest done by splitting it up into separate problems: For any arbitrary interest, a protocol to check if Alice and Bob share that interest. Doing the whole set is then a matter of repeating the protocol across a finite set of possible interests. So we’ll deal with the simpler problem of checking if they share interests.

    Let’s assume that Alice and Bob already have an authenticated channel set up (i.e. Eve can’t pretend to be Bob) - e.g. because they’ve previously exchanged public keys through a secure channel.

    Zero-Knowledge (ZK) protocols come in Interactive and Non-Interactive flavours. Here, we’ll need an interactive protocol, because otherwise Bob could run the same protocol twice, once saying he does have the interest, and once saying he doesn’t.

    This problem is almost identical to the Socialist Millionaire Problem, except you don’t want to leak information if Alice and Bob don’t share the interest.

    Alice and Bob calculate their respective x_ij values (where i=0 for Alice, i=1 for Bob), such that x_ij is 0 if participant i has interest j, and a large random number if not.

    They then use a Socialist Millionaire Protocol (e.g. the one from the OTR messaging protocol in the above linked article) to check if x_0j is equal to x_1j. If they both picked 0 (have the interest), the protocol tells then their values are the same. If one of them has interest j and one doesn’t, the one with the interest learns the other does not have the interest, while the other party learns nothing (except that the other party didn’t pick the same large random number). If they both don’t have the interest, they only learn that the other picked a different large random number or zero, but can’t tell between the two. Assuming sufficiently large numbers, it is vanishingly unlikely they’d pick the same number.

    The interactive protocol can be run in parallel for each interest j, but has a few sequential steps per interest (ensuring neither party can cheat and have more than one choice per interest).


  • To be Kafkaesque is to not know what you are accused of and/or to have no real mechanism to defend the accusations. The Kafkaesque part is the private network of ‘justice’ that makes judgements which impact someone’s access to basics like food based on an opaque algorithm with no recourse.

    These private systems are worst when they are networks across multiple stores - you could imagine a future where, if left to the devices of late stage capitalism (i.e. not effectively regulated), it could become virtually impossible to buy food and other essentials once you are on a privately held denylist that retailers pay to access, where those on the list have no insights into how they got on the list nor any mechanism to correct any inaccuracies that unfairly led to them being on the list.

    TL;DR: I think Kafkaesque is correct here.



  • Russia has used their surface-to-air missiles to attack ground-based targets (particularly when short of other missiles), so just because that’s not their primary purpose doesn’t mean they can’t be used for that.

    That said, missiles are very expensive and their benefit to an attacker is their long range, so insurrectionists would likely only use them for long range attacks when they can’t get close to their targets.

    That said, it’s definitely putting nearby civilians at risk - and so is highly inappropriate as opposed to moving Trump somewhere else, like the White House where he should be anyway, rather than a club that’s been repeatedly mentioned in relation to Epstein. It’s prioritising something other than public safety for sure.


  • I wish people would stop repeating without evidence the idea that Luigi M did anything other than get harassed eating at a fast food restaurant. The official story makes no sense - someone apparently recognised him from a blurry CCTV release that is likely another person albeit of the same build and hair colour, and phoned it in with absolute certainty, and then the police happened to find a ‘manifesto’ on him, and then later, not even straight away when he was searched, an improvised weapon. If the real killer could do the crime and get away to a completely different state, they’d have had numerous opportunities to dispose of everything - it just strains credibility.

    Consider on the other hand that the powers that be were eager that someone take the fall for this - they couldn’t have the perception that such a thing will go unpunished (see also: the extreme push for the death penalty, and the involvement of very senior political appointees). They can achieve that by picking any random approximately fitting the description off the street and framing them.



  • If these are relatively inexpensive to set up and dispose of, corporations could even set them up automatically for individual consumer transactions and between individual employees and themselves.

    For example, you go to a fast food restaurant, and you are actually being served by McGermKing Franchise 6d8f3cee-b10b-442b-b00b-02683a709f70 Ltd, founded 2 seconds ago, and leasing the right to operate in the building amongst other similar AI companies, as well as the part-time services of McGermKing Employment Services fd176cc4-bb95-4c1b-80e7-2aec39f02917, who hires a human to take your order, and McGermKing Employment Services 5336b4f1-0594-4df1-8387-5ec9b638db77, who assembles your GermBurger (TM used under licence by McGermKing Franchise 6d8f3cee-b10b-442b-b00b-02683a709f70 Ltd).

    If you pay them and they make money, it goes back to the owner. If you get food poisoning and sue McGermKing Franchise 6d8f3cee-b10b-442b-b00b-02683a709f70 Ltd (since the parent company is totally innocent and some other subsidiaries are just honest suppliers), it comes out of the money they made selling you the burger, and if their liability to you was higher than the cost of one burger, well, the AI corporation tried its honest best at business, but you can line up for your share of the payout - keeping in mind they also owe franchise fees to the parent company out of that burger, so the AI liquidator will divide up the assets, and if it doesn’t cover liabilities, the parent company loses its 50c investment into McGermKing Franchise 6d8f3cee-b10b-442b-b00b-02683a709f70 Ltd, and how sad it was a bad outcome for you as a creditor.

    Likewise if an employee gets hurt, same story.


  • The current Congo outbreak is of Bundibugyo Virus(BDBV), a different species of orthoebolavirus that is less treatable than EBOV.

    There are monoclonal antibody treatments not specifically designed for BDBV that offer limited protection against worse outcome for BDBV, but I don’t think the prognosis is great for the people getting affected because the MABs available only offer limited neutralising ability. There is also not yet an effective vaccine for BDBV.

    There are cultural funeral practices that are contributing to the spread of BDBV in Congo (i.e. people demanding that tradition be followed when it is likely to infect them), and inequalities in access to care which I’m sure have some impact.

    However, ultimately there is nothing Africa-specific about the family of viruses (apart from which wildlife they originated in) that mean they couldn’t spread in another country or have similar case-fatality rates there.



  • This is not running it as root (i.e. privileged userland, still ring 3), this is running it as ring 0 (i.e. the level that the kernel runs at, with no restrictions on access to memory and hardware at all). A tiny bug in ring 0 code can take down the system or open security vulnerabilities, where the kernel can provide more hardening to protect applications to an extent.

    You could say this is the inner circle of hell.


  • Trump has showed some minimal level of deference to the Rome Statute, presumably so he doesn’t risk ever appearing at the ICC - for example, Trump waited until Venezuela left the Rome statute in December 2025 before ordering the invasion in January 2026 (probably a good reason for other countries to consider ratifying / not renouncing the Rome Statute). He has used Israel to do his dirty work in his plans to take over the Gaza Strip to give a layer of plausible deniability (Palestine is a Rome statute signatory). He has picked on non-Rome-Statute countries (e.g. Iran, which signed but have said they won’t ratify) and Yemen (signed but didn’t ratify).

    Trump is known for trying to dismantle any constraint on what he can do from anyone - US citizens (see January 6th 2021), US courts, US Congress (see his efforts against the midterms), major trade partners (see his US isolationist policies), and so the fact that the ICC might hold him accountable one day is likely a terrible affront to his insecure self-actualisation.

    I think every country of the world should try to sign up for the Rome Statute so leaders like Trump are held accountable, and work to nullify US sanctions. Banks, for example, should have to choose between operating in countries other than the US, or following US sanctions that are not approved by other countries (or at least, specific sanctions the country decides are unacceptable).


  • Yep, and if you’re a real techbro, you start off by making the offering great. But then, you gradually enshittify it. Popups start coming up that ask her to consent to things she doesn’t really want forever, on unconscionable terms, but at first there is a ‘Yes’ or ‘Not now’ option. Behind the scenes, there are terms saying you can change the terms any time you like, and her only option is to leave within 14 days, and it is her responsibility to monitor the terms and stop using it if she doesn’t agree. You start silently changing the terms to allow you to opt her in by default to consent to things she doesn’t want. She opts out, so you change the terms again so she has no choice. All the while the service gets worse - but what’s she going to do, she’s locked in.

    And that sort of thing is why working for companies known for doing the equivalent of the above but to the public is not going to get a good reaction.


  • But I also think he did really believe in electric cars and solar power

    Musk is very good at separating wealthy investors from their money. Said investors are not entirely stupid - but Musk has historically been very skilled at cultivating a perception that he’s going to do something revolutionary that will change the world and make his investors rich, if only investors would give him money. You know, that he can colonise mars, build fully self-driving (on motorways) cars by 2015, and build a practical LA to SF hyperloop.

    To con investors he was an amazing futurist, there needed to be a grain of truth mixed in there, even if there were other significant logical gaps in his claims. I don’t believe he genuinely cared about the planet or other people, but he did see (as many people were, in fact, already screaming) that change was coming and decide he could sell it to investors and enrich himself.

    Pretending to be an amazing engineer and to care was his modus operandi for a long time - perhaps the most notable incident was in the 2018 Tham Luang cave incident in Thailand; Musk pledged to put engineers on inventing a submarine to rescue them. When Tesla’s design was unlikely to work, but a heroic team of divers rescued the children, instead of expressing relief the children were safe, Musk labelled the rescuer a ‘pedo’, showing that he never really cared and it was just a stunt.


  • The Dunning-Kruger paper was later discredited because, ironically, Dunning & Kruger thought they were better at statistics than they actually were!

    There is a dark triad of personality disorders that often occur together: psychopathy (lack of empathy for others), Machiavellianism (manipulative) and narcissism. High narc people boast they are the greatest even if they are pretty terrible (but it’s not Dunning-Kruger because even if miraculously a high narc person became mediocre instead of poor at something they claim they are good at, they’ll still think they are good rather than reflecting on what they now know they don’t know).


  • The quotes from the business owners in that article who feel so entitled to not pay their staff a living wage and then blame their customers for not making up the shortfall are infuriating: “If they don’t receive any tips, it’s impossible to survive in the service industry”, “It’s just to protect our staff”. Well if you really care about the waitstaff getting paid a living wage, how about this, pay them a living wage and stop trying to blame your customers for a problem you created.

    Of course, part of the problem is that they don’t want to advertise the true cost - they want to advertise a price that is lower than the actual price, and then say stuff like the above to guilt their customers into paying more than the advertised price. With their competitors doing the same, it’s a race to the bottom dynamic. So the real solution is for the local government to: 1) require businesses to advertise the actual total amount of cash customers will have to hand over and not some misleading number, with enforcement if businesses mislead, 2) set a livable minimum wage, with no exceptions, and serious and well enforced penalties for employers that steal wages. If they did both of those things, then the problem would likely solve itself quickly.



  • Attacking a military ship is generally not a war crime (as defined by international law such as the Geneva treaties, Rome Statute etc…). It is an act of war (same as invasion or bombardment of another country), and is likely to see retaliation by the attacked country.

    Aggression (i.e. unprovoked acts of war) is against the Charter of the United Nations, which also includes the International Court of Justice as a dispute resolution mechanism. It is up to the United Nations Security Council (at which the US has a veto) to authorise enforcement of ICJ rulings.

    If a nation is acting to protect another nation facing aggression from the US, it would be legal for the attack US military ships. The reason why they wouldn’t would more be that it would likely bring counter-retaliation from the US.


  • So back in 1994 my neighbours and I agreed that I’d give them my anti-theft fog cannons, as long as they promise not to steal my stuff.

    Then in 2014 they sent some buddies in to burgle my place, and got away with a chunk of my stuff - and I know it was said neighbour behind it, because they now openly claim what was taken is theirs (of course, I never agreed with them on that).

    Then since February 2022 they’ve started regularly burgling my place - in the first few weeks, they tried to take literally everything, but fortunately I hired good security guards and they only got away with about 20% of my stuff (including what they stole in 2014).

    I’ve been trying to make arrangements for a monitored alarm system that will bring in a large external response if more burglaries happen, but the security company doesn’t want to take it on the contract while a burglary is in progress - but they did sell me some gear. I’m still working on getting the contract.

    They say they’ll stop trying to burgle my place as long as I promise not to ever get a monitored burglar alarm, to officially sign over the property they’ve already stolen and to stop trying to get it back, stop buying stuff to protect my property from the monitored security company, and that I fire most of my security guards.

    Do you think this is really their end game, or if I agree, do you think they’ll just be back burgling more as soon as I make those promises, with fewer security guards and stuff to protect my house? After all, I did have an agreement with them back in 1994 and they didn’t follow that.